Edgar Pomeroy

[kirsch]

I know some of you have told me about this guy in other posts, but I wanted to open it up for all to see...

Has anyone had any personal experience or heard anything about Edgar Pomeroy in Atlanta, GA, USA?

I contacted a member of his staff today, and that person was very knowledgeable and professional---truly bespoke. I have heard some negative comments about Pomeroy before, however. Just wanted to know if anyone had any additional comments on him (pos or neg).


Thanks,
Chris

[Chris Rimby]

I already mentioned that he definitely seems to have a bad reputation....everything from his attitude to his suits. If you're really wanting the bespoke experience see Thomas Mahon next week.

Chris

[masterfred]

I responded to an earlier question about Pomeroy. I haven't used his customized service, so can't speak to that aspect. Pomeroy does come across as somewhat arrogant or smug, but you can find that in many another retail establishment. He used to utilize Martin Greenfield for his tailored clothing, but may have since hired an actual tailor for the shop. However, let me say that he once had some really great stuff in his store - braces, ties, pocket squares, even ascots. Rather pricey, but at the times I visited, no more so than NM or Saks in Atlanta. His assistant (I believe her name was Jennifer' don't know if she's still there) was a very pleasant and professional person. It is a small establishment, and doesn't have a huge selection, so you can't just show up and browse as easily as you can in a large luxury department store.

As far as his tailored clothing goes, it's not bad at all in terms of construction. The one suit I've seen on a client of his didn't fit so well - the collar stood well off his neck. The design is a rather stylized version of what most of us think of as Savile Row - shaped waisting, slightly wider lapels, forward pleated trousers, etc. FWIW, my couple of visits to Pomeroy were certainly more pleasant than my experience with a similar outfit in NYC - the Domenico Spano shop in Saks.

[kirsch]

Well it seems that Pomeroy has more negative comments than positive...not a good sign.

I guess the problem I have is, while I think Mahon is amazing, he is a bit out of my price range at this point (I just graduated college last year and am now in my first job).

That's not to say that Pomeroy is inexpensive, but the prices Jennifer told me were about 1300 less for a three-piece.

In addition, he is in Atlanta (as am I). Which seems like it would make things easier.


So what's your guys' opinions? Should just keep saving for a while and wait to get one made by Mahon when he is in Atlanta next, or give Pomeroy a try?

[Concordia]

As long as you're not buying today, why not visit both to get a sense of where the land lies? Thomas is pretty busy but may be able to spare 10 minutes if you let him know why you are looking.

[alden]

Concordia has given you the best advice. I am not in any position to make a judgement about Mr. Pomeroy. On the other hand, the ability to have a suit from Mr. Mahon while he is making a regular stop in Atlanta would be excellent if possible. If Atlantians give their custom to Mr. Mahon, it will insure his visits continue. That saves alot of you flights to Cumbria, though you would be advised to make the trip one day to see the beautiful Warwick Hall.

Save your money and learn how to become a good customer. Understand what it is you will need for your career and make a plan. If you have questions, ask them here. If you choose wisely, a very modest number of well made suits crafted from solid cloth can last you many decades. So the incremental cost per suit is not as much the issue as building a long term wardobe plan.

Best regards.

M Alden

[iammatt]

Just to second the post above, the more intelligent questions you ask around here, the faster you will learn to appreciate new things and to know what you might want.

As a relative neophyte, I have found not only the discussion to be interesting, but the most knowledgeable members to be open and helpful whether on the board or by PM for specific questions.

[manton]

I have known a few Pomeroy customers over the years, and all of them have voiced varying levels of frustration. Mere hearsay, but approach with caution.

[kirsch]

thank you all for your help!

--Chris

[Chris Rimby]

I thouight of another possible option for you (and me as well!). Desmond Merrion is a UK based tailor who has started to visit the USA. He just made his first trip to NYC and I'm trying to get him to add Atlanta to his schedule next time he comes to town (late January/early Feb.) Desmond has a MTM option that is priced lower than his bespoke prices. The suit is still 100% hand constructed by Desmond...no outsourcing. Check out his prices:

http://www.desmerrionbespoketailor.com/ ... on/prices/

If this might work for you let Desmond know. Maybe we can have two world class tailors regularly visiting Atlanta!

[dopey]

I thouight of another possible option for you (and me as well!). Desmond Merrion is a UK based tailor who has started to visit the USA. He just made his first trip to NYC and I'm trying to get him to add Atlanta to his schedule next time he comes to town (late January/early Feb.) Desmond has a MTM option that is priced lower than his bespoke prices. The suit is still 100% hand constructed by Desmond...no outsourcing. Check out his prices:

http://www.desmerrionbespoketailor.com/ ... on/prices/

If this might work for you let Desmond know. Maybe we can have two world class tailors regularly visiting Atlanta!

I think you have to look here for a description of Des’s MTM. The differences between that and his bespoke are more than just the pattern. The MTM has a fused front with a canvas chest-piece and there is less hand-sewing. On the other hand, the fitting process is more or less the same as with his bespoke. I suggest you discuss the differences with him directly. I never did and all I know about it is what is on his website. I expect I will know more about his bespoke product in time, but I can certainly say that he is a decent and straightforward guy.

[Chris Rimby]

I thouight of another possible option for you (and me as well!). Desmond Merrion is a UK based tailor who has started to visit the USA. He just made his first trip to NYC and I'm trying to get him to add Atlanta to his schedule next time he comes to town (late January/early Feb.) Desmond has a MTM option that is priced lower than his bespoke prices. The suit is still 100% hand constructed by Desmond...no outsourcing. Check out his prices:

http://www.desmerrionbespoketailor.com/ ... on/prices/

If this might work for you let Desmond know. Maybe we can have two world class tailors regularly visiting Atlanta!

I think you have to look here for a description of Des’s MTM. The differences between that and his bespoke are more than just the pattern. The MTM has a fused front with a canvas chest-piece and there is less hand-sewing. On the other hand, the fitting process is more or less the same as with his bespoke. I suggest you discuss the differences with him directly. I never did and all I know about it is what is on his website. I expect I will know more about his bespoke product in time, but I can certainly say that he is a decent and straightforward guy.

Of course. Research is always required.

Have you commissioned a piece from Desmond?