Page 1 of 1
Hackett vs Ricci
Posted: Wed Apr 02, 2014 2:51 pm
by andreyb
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1revai8KRA0
An interesting video, demonstrating two things:
1) Shoulder padding sometimes might be quite good
2) Good manners are always good, even in the most unnerving circumstances
Andrey
Re: Hackett vs Ricci
Posted: Wed Apr 02, 2014 2:58 pm
by gegarrenton
Very interesting video I dare say. Thanks for that.
Re: Hackett vs Ricci
Posted: Wed Apr 02, 2014 3:32 pm
by hectorm
andreyb wrote:An interesting video, demonstrating two things
And it demonstrates a third:
"traduttore, traditore"
Although in this case, the interpreter was also being a diplomat.
Re: Hackett vs Ricci
Posted: Wed Apr 02, 2014 6:30 pm
by andreyb
hectorm wrote:And it demonstrates a third: "traduttore, traditore"
Although in this case, the interpreter was also being a diplomat.
?
I don't speak Italian (and hardly speak English
), so can't understand what Ricci really said. Is he harsher or milder?
Andrey
Re: Hackett vs Ricci
Posted: Thu Apr 03, 2014 11:38 am
by Frederic Leighton
Ricci wrote:Lui sta simulando un'immagine che non gli e' propria, che non gli e' congenita, e quindi sta assicurando se stesso. Io non ho questa filosofia; io sono per la verita'. [...] L'eleganza e' dote dell'uomo, non del vestito. Con o senza spallina, lui resta pur sempre una persona elegante e gli rivolgo i miei piu' vivi e sentiti complimenti.
He is simulating an image that doesn't belong to him, that isn't innate in him, and therefore he's reassuring himself. This isn't my philosophy. I believe in truth. [...]
Elegance is a quality of man, not of his cloths. With or without shoulder-pad, he keeps being an elegant person and I offer him my warmest and heartfelt congratulations.
How can a man in navy blue worsted and one in green herringbone tweed agree? Good manners on both sides, though; just different cultures. It reminds me of a cafe in Old Street, a rat running at full speed across the room and me smashing it under my foot without thinking once - an innate reflex. Dirty rat 0-1 Italy. Few seconds later, ladies crying and terrible glances from all directions.
Re: Hackett vs Ricci
Posted: Thu Apr 03, 2014 12:23 pm
by Russell
Frederic Leighton wrote:
It reminds me of a cafe in Old Street, a rat running at full speed across the room and me smashing it under my foot without thinking once - an innate reflex.
Was he anyone we knew?
Regards
Russell
PS Nice reflexes!
Re: Hackett vs Ricci
Posted: Thu Apr 03, 2014 4:33 pm
by hectorm
Frederic Leighton wrote:Just different cultures. It reminds me of a cafe in Old Street, a rat running at full speed across the room and me smashing it under my foot without thinking once - an innate reflex. Dirty rat 0-1 Italy. Few seconds later, ladies crying and terrible glances from all directions.
Same scene at an elegant tea room in Mayfair many years ago: nobody had that kind of innate reflex but the waiter, who -far from smashing the rat- started explaining out loud to the disturbed clientele that it was just "Little Peter", the house pet.
Re: Hackett vs Ricci
Posted: Thu Apr 03, 2014 4:34 pm
by Luca
Frederic Leighton wrote: a rat running at full speed across the room and me smashing it under my foot without thinking once - an innate reflex. Dirty rat 0-1 Italy. Few seconds later, ladies crying and terrible glances from all directions.
Much as I like frequenting the "third places" around that part of London, so close to my office, that's what you get for hanging around "damn hippies"
Re: Hackett vs Ricci
Posted: Thu Apr 03, 2014 7:23 pm
by hectorm
andreyb wrote: can't understand what Ricci really said. Is he harsher or milder?
Dear
andreyb,
Mr. Ricci criticizes Mr. Hackett´s coat style (particularly the shoulder padding) saying things like "
If you hide your shoulders, you hide yourself" or "
you must embrace your sloping shoulders". He says it nicely but comes up a bit too much straightforward which could be taken as impolite in some cultures. The interpreter is trying to convey the ideas more smoothly. Mr. Hackett notices what´s going on and takes it like a gentleman.
Re: Hackett vs Ricci
Posted: Sat Apr 05, 2014 6:41 am
by robert_n
I think Ricci makes a good point, but I didn't like his shoulders either, or rather the very prominent sleeve head.
Re: Hackett vs Ricci
Posted: Sat Apr 05, 2014 3:42 pm
by Luca
A video can easily miss crucial context. Based purely on what was shown, I found Ricci less than polite. Far less. And not a little bit pompous. We Italians can get that way.
Re: Hackett vs Ricci
Posted: Sat Apr 05, 2014 3:55 pm
by Russell
We all (thankfully) have our own sense of what looks good even if it's perhaps not what we'd wear ourselves.
Although no fan of thickly padded shoulders, if I saw Mr Hackett in the street I'd be thinking ”smart man”; if I saw Mr Ricci I'd be thinking ”what a Pitti".
Regards
Russell
Re: Hackett vs Ricci
Posted: Sun Apr 06, 2014 2:01 am
by robert_n
http://www.thesartorialist.com/photos/o ... -florence/
Ricci has quite a fondness for very prominent sleeve heads. Tutti i gusti sono gusti.
Re: Hackett vs Ricci
Posted: Sun Apr 06, 2014 2:58 am
by robert_n
I mean the sleeve heads seem exaggerated, as though designed to draw attention to the artisan's work. As horrible as the deliberately unfastened last button on a coat sleeve. Da cafone.
Re: Hackett vs Ricci
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2014 12:43 am
by hectorm
Russell wrote: If I saw Mr Ricci I'd be thinking ”what a Pitti".
That´s a good one, Russell. An "original" for me. I will use it in the future.