Ask a Neapolitan

[Screaminmarlon]

So, it should really be called 'in the end, I asked an English'

[kamil]

Yes, it's been a long way but I ended up in square one.

[Scot]

To paraphrase Churchill, it looks like a case of arriving at the correct decision after exhausting all the alternatives

[soren]

Kamil, did you decide if you will make it a shawl cardigan?

Funny you should mention it, I have actually handed my Etna cashmere to my (Italian) tailor to have made a shawl collared jacket very much with the same qualities as requested here; minimal structure and lining so the end result should hopefully be something in-between a cardigan and a jacket. Patch pockets of course. For a while I considered raglan shoulders as well, but thought it might make it too, ehm, odd in the end.

(PS: please don't ban me for unorthodox use of LL cloth )