New Alsport

[dufossat]

I am considering having something made from John G. Hardy's new Alsport range. I have had clothes made from some of the old range (both 16oz and 19oz) and really enjoy them.

I like several of the new patterns but some of the members here consider the new range to be inferior to the old. I frankly cannot tell much difference by handling the swatches. If anyone has actual experience in making or wearing clothes from the new Alsport range I would appreciate hearing about it.

[old henry]

The new Alsport is a far cry from the old. It is limp and lifeless compared to the old.The old was prickly and rough and when you sponged it it smelled of the sheep. And the colors popped. Take both books in hand and handle them. You will see.This is another tragedy. However, However.. Look to Johnstons of Elgin Thornproofs. Also Bateman Ogden has a good heavy tweed. FS

[Rowly]

How do Johnstons of Elgin Thornproofs compare with Porter and Harding Thornproofs? What are the merits of Hartwist or Glenroyal, in terms of suiting?

[old henry]

Porter & Harding is a very good thornproof but I like the rough, tough, thick hand and the authentic, vintage Upper Highland colors of the Johnstons. Porter & Harding will make up strong and I love making them when I do. W.Bill used to make the most satisfying , handsome thornproof but ... The Hartwist and Glenroyal ? It has been so long since I have handled them,Rowly, I should check in with my books before I answer you, but I know they are very good.. Frank

[Rowly]

Thanks Frank, I take it it's the Glenhunt you refer to in Bateman Ogden. I have my eye on a blue herringbone from that book. The herringbones seem very pronounced and tactile!

[old henry]

Yes, Thats it. Good choice.

[Rowly]

Thanks Frank, good advice!