Fri Sep 05, 2008 12:26 am
This is the last scene where we see Kitteridge. He lacks the personality of C.K. Dexter Haven or Jimmy Stewart. He is uptight. He expects "Red" to act a certain way, which she did not on their wedding eve (at least according to him).
A highlight of this scene is when, during Kitteridge's interrogation and responding to how his wife shoud behave, she says stiffly and in a formal way that mocks Kitteridge's tone - "To behave herself - - - naturally." What she means is "obviously to act as 'high society' - (catch the reference?) expects." This is a Kitteridgesque monotone mechanical response, to which C.K. Dexter Haven quickly replies, in his oh so smart aleck way and in a much different tone, "To behave herself naturally". What he means, which is in direct contrast to what Red and Kitteridge mean is to naturally act as one wishes - to follow one's instincts instead of societal norms.
The differences between these identical lines delivered one after the other shows Hepburn and C.G. at their best. Her delivery is mechanical (which she had previously done unecessarily in other films to much justified criticism), but necessary. C.G.'s is masterful. What she is saying is (imagine this Robotically) "T-o b-e-h-a-v-e m-y-s-e-l-f n-a-t-u-r-a-l-l-y s-i-r". What CG conveys is the non "virgin goddess" part of Red to let her Lydiaish inner child come out and "to behave herself naturally".
C.G. as Dex, the now tee-totaller is telling Red to throw caution to the wind. Get tipsy. Drunkenly swim with a stranger at night. Then the next morning, cancel society's biggest wedding only to replace it with a wedding to your first husband (not even the man you drunkely kissed the night before) who will let you be who you want if you will only let him. He will not self-destruct this time through booze if she will not be too Kitteridgely rigid with her Virgin Goddess beliefs.
Throughout this scene I think that it is at this very part, when Red utters these very words that she, as Deborah Kerr said to C.G. in "An Affair to Remember", charted a new course and changed her course forever. When she utters these words she realizes that she cannot marry Kitteridge. I believe that it is when Dex immediately repeats her same words in his much different way that Red's and Dex's fate is sealed and that they will stroll down the wedding plank again.
Pretend that you had never seen this movie before. Just before Red utters these lines, do you know what will happen. Kitteridge appears out, but not totally. Jimmy Stewart's lips were last on Red's. Cary Grant lingers. Do you know what will happen?
Now let these two same lines pass - delivered by two different people - one right after the other. Is there any doubt, after these lines are uttered, how this movie will end. Red will marry Dex - not her fiance, not the man she last kissed. These lines tell all.
Sorry this is long. This is a great scene. You wanted one-liners. I delivered a tome.
Great catch NJS on this important, but easy to overlook part of a scene.
Trey